Radio Recap: Dark Fantasy

Of all the old-time radio horror programs, Dark Fantasy certainly stands apart. It's a series I learned of relatively late; around 1997 I bought a set of cassettes from Radio Spirits called "Old-Time Radio's Greatest Mysteries" which included 3 episodes of Dark Fantasy. I always enjoy finding another example of OTR horror and I was surprised that I'd heard nothing of it before - my local radio station QR77 never played a single episode; I had never heard it on Yesterday USA; John Dunning did not give the series an entry in his book On the Air: The Encyclopedia of Old Time Radio.

Dark Fantasy was the brainchild of a writer named Scott Bishop. He was apparently a prolific author, although I've never found evidence of it. A press release for the launch of Dark Fantasy asserted he was "father of hundreds of mystery novels," yet I haven't seen any of them in bibliographies of pulp novels. An episode of Dark Fantasy titled "House of Bread" featured Bishop himself as the lead character, who is told by his publisher his books are "selling like peanuts at a circus." Mere wishful thinking? Ego-stroking? Did Bishop publish his fiction under a psuedonym? Perhaps one day I'll know.

Understanding who Bishop is and where he came from might help explain why Dark Fantasy is the series that it is. It should be noted that it aired from November 14, 1941 to June 26, 1942 over WKY, an NBC affiliate in Oklahoma City - thus, the series wasn't heard nation-wide. Airing when it did, the most obvious influences on Dark Fantasy would have been programs like the Witch's Tale and Lights Out.

How can I describe this series? I suppose you can divide Dark Fantasy into two types of episodes if you want to grossly oversimplify:

1. Episodes with consistent tones.
2. Episodes with inconsistent tones.

Those of the former are productions with very even plots. Characters and situations are introduced, a complication appears, something weird happens (usually something supernatural although occasionally sci-fi in origin) and the story ends. For example there's the episode "Resolution, 1841" in which four friends get together over the holidays; they banter together, mention is made that one woman has some financial troubles; later, one of them is possessed by the ghost of the woman's grandfather and he reveals where he hid a fortune.

In the latter, scenes lurch from one to the next with no sense of momentum. The weird things that occur are given next-to-zero build-up. For example there's the episode "The Cup of Gold" in which a golfer is killed; a woman who is supposedly responsible for the murder doesn't recall doing it; then some incense is lit and teleports the woman and her accuser to the planet Vento; a resident of Vento explains the woman is a reincarnation of a woman from Vento and she killed the golfer because they were enemies in previous lives. But when I type it like that I make it sound much more coherant than it is to hear.

Dark Fantasy was low budget; sound effects were usually limited, even small things like footsteps and doors closing were often omitted. Consequently, much of the show seems to be characters exchanging dialogue in a void - there's seldom a sense of place or atmosphere and those elements are so important in horror. Most of the drama is put over through dialogue and that becomes wearying, especially with the sotto voce style Bishop seemed to prefer from his actors. Whereas in the Witch's Tale or Lights Out characters would often scream their dialogue to convey terror, Dark Fantasy performers tend to lower their voices into whispers, as though in quiet awe of whatever was happening. It is extremely ineffective.

Dark Fantasy is camp, but not in the way Inner Sanctum Mysteries is - there's no sense that Scott Bishop meant his program to be intentionally over-the-top, even when he penned "Spawn of the Subhuman," a story about a gorilla given the voice of an opera singer by a mad scientist. Dark Fantasy took itself quite seriously, like Lights Out, but there's nothing deeper going on- while Arch Oboler liked his Lights Out stories to serve as commentaries about the world around himself (especially as commentaries on fascism), I have no idea what Scott Bishop valued nor abhorred. The man liked to write horror stories and NBC was willing to pay him for those stories.

If you want horror, Dark Fantasy does sometimes come through; "the Demon Tree" and "the Headless Dead" are both stories with a big supernatural threat tied to a plot that flows very evenly; you might get a kick out of them. Other stories are extremely pulpy, such as the sci-fi tale "Men Call Me Mad" about a visit to a micro-world, or the African adventure tale "The Thing from the Darkness."

Old Time Radio Researchers have a YouTube playlist of Dark Fantasy.